|
Date: May 20, 2004
Commencement Address at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced
International Studies, Washington, D.C.
Ladies
and Gentlemen of the SAIS Class of 2004, it is a very great honor for me
to join you, your families and friends and the leadership, faculty and
staff of our school to pay tribute to you today.
When
you think about it, there is no comparable day on any year’s
calendar so full of the sense of satisfaction that you all must
feel, and of promise and hope for your futures, than graduation
day. Today is all about you. This is your moment, your hour,
your day when we recognize your considerable achievements and send
you off into the world to do great things.
Now,
before we go too far overboard in praising you, we should rightfully
recognize first the people who also made this day possible—your parents
and family members and your teachers. They dreamed of your attaining what
is now an essential feature of an educated life in America and around the
world—a graduate degree at one of the world’s great universities. And
your parents, especially, have paid, in more ways than one, for that
distinction. As they helped make today possible for you, would it not be
appropriate for all the graduates to rise and salute your parents with an
enthusiastic round of thanks and applause!
They say that
graduation day is one of the most five significant anniversaries of one’s
life, along with birth, marriage, death and the most momentous day of
all—when you finally pay off your student loans. I just can’t promise you
can count on that coming before or after death!
Let me tell you that
I am acutely conscious of the fact that I am the only person standing in
the way of you and your diplomas, so I don’t intend to regale you with all
my stories of life in the Foreign Service. But, I do want to communicate
how fortunate I think you are to be in your caps and gowns today and to
have so much ahead of you that is good and positive.
If there was ever a
graduate school so perfectly constructed and inspired by the
internationalist ideal that has been, since the end of the Second World
War, the central foundation of our globalized world, it is surely the
Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies.
Like thousands of
others, I am enormously proud to be among its graduates. In my years here
in the late 1970s, we were half the size student body that you are now.
And to give you a sense of the incredible changes in student life since
then, not a single one of us owned a personal computer, a cell phone or a
blackberry because they did not exist! In fact, I felt technologically
advanced and was the envy of my classmates when I arrived at SAIS with my
electric typewriter and its correcting cartridge—the very model of a
futuristic machine. SAIS was then fully contained in one building at
1740 Mass. Ave. Most of us focused intellectually on the Cold War
stand-off between NATO and the Soviet Union. Many supported President
Jimmy Carter’s campaign for human rights in the Third World. Upon
graduation, a good number of my friends headed directly for New York and
Wall Street where they arrived right at the start of the investment
banking boom of the 1980s. Some became so wealthy that they retired well
before forty. I hear from my SAIS pals from time to time and they are
amazed that I’m still working at the venerable age of 48. It’s at that
point that I remind them of the cold reality of U.S. government pay
scales.
SAIS grads all around
the globe will welcome you enthusiastically to our ranks when the diploma
hits your hand in just a few minutes time. I can tell you from personal
experience that the very first thing that will happen when that magical
moment arrives is you will receive a letter from the Hopkins Alumni
Association delivered right to your seat here in Constitution Hall asking
you to donate your millions (but they also accept pennies) to this year’s
fundraising campaign.
There are many
pretenders to the throne of the world’s finest graduate school in
international affairs—in Boston, New York, Princeton, Paris, London and
even one across town here in Washington D.C.-- but I trust you will all
agree as loyal soon-to-be alums that SAIS is the undisputed best school of
its kind across the globe.
There is no other
school quite like ours. We had a unique beginning. We were founded at
the close of World War Two by wise men and women led by Paul Nitze and
Christian Herter. Their greatest generation created the United Nations,
the IMF and World Bank, the OECD, and the strongest military alliance in
history—NATO. And they created SAIS because they knew that America
required a graduate school that would encourage its students, as well as
international students, toward careers in the governments that have helped
to produce two generations of peace on both sides of the Atlantic, and in
the great financial houses that built the unprecedented prosperity we
enjoy today.
We have a unique
global presence through our school in Nanjing, our focus on Latin America,
our expertise in Middle Eastern affairs, our long history of interest in
Africa and our half century presence in Bologna where I had such a
memorable day with your fellow SAIS students last week fielding their
thoughtful but tough questions while dodging the communist and anarchist
demonstrators who were nice enough to greet me upon my arrival.
Since my time here,
SAIS has doubled foreign student enrollment, strengthened Asian studies
and International Development, created Conflict Management and a
discipline called Energy, Environment, Science and Technology which
probably deserves a new name but is surely an important program given the
centrality of those issues to modern diplomacy.
We have a unique
curriculum. No other school is so determined to turn out well-rounded
graduates that it forces students to slave over the intricacies of
International Economics as well as Foreign Languages. My classmates and I
disliked that spartan regimen at the time but we could not have survived
subsequently in our professional lives without it. SAIS takes a
consciously different approach to international affairs education. We
have neither a solely liberal arts regime nor a purely scientific nor a
vocational approach. We don’t even have learning for learning’s sake! We
combine the experience and wisdom of academia, business, labor,
non-governmental organizations and government itself into a protean whole.
We have a unique and
extraordinary faculty led by our energetic, committed and inspiring Dean,
Jessica Einhorn who has done a magnificent job in her first two years.
We have wise and approachable Professors such as the very first person I
met at SAIS, Fred Holborn, who has contributed a lifetime of intelligence,
wit and devotion to our school; Fouad Ajami who has brought a unique blend
of eloquence, scholarship and personal insight to the hard choices facing
us in the Middle East; Riordon Roett who has championed the study of
Brazil and Latin America; and Eliot Cohen, one of the most influential
strategic thinkers of our time whom I was happy to greet in Belgium this
winter when he led the large and enthusiastic SAIS Security Studies staff
ride to Waterloo, Ypres and Bastogne.
Finally, we have the
world’s most uniquely enthusiastic alumni network—9,000 strong in 143
countries. In just the last few months, I have met with SAIS alumni
groups in Brussels, Rome, Milan and Bologna. All are committed to the
school. Our fellow grads are running foreign ministries and armies,
Fortune 500 firms and non-governmental organizations. We seek each other
out, stay in touch and preserve the special bond that comes with being a
graduate of this truly unique institution.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
every graduation speech ever delivered can be boiled down to the same
theme—go forth and do good things in the world. And, that is the one
message I wish to give you today. This commencement day is your call to
service.
We need the 315 of
you to serve in the government ministries of your 66 countries. We need
you to lead the growing number of non-governmental organizations making a
crucial difference in the Third World and in tough places like Baghdad,
Kabul, Khartoum and East Timor. We need you to run for political office
as democracy spreads from the Americas to Africa and across the Greater
Middle East. We need you to be enlightened and ethical leaders of the
great corporations and financial institutions that are the key to global
growth and higher living standards. In short, we need you to think of
your futures as a call to service.
I am not talking
about the austere and often poverty stricken stereotype of service that
the words often imply (although U. S. government service sometimes
inspires that definition) but a broader notion of service based on what
you can do best for the greater good in both the public and private
sectors. Public service is still the highest calling and it has always
been so. Why else would the ancient Greeks have used the word “idiot” to
describe those who disavowed service to the public!
We ask you to
consider public service for one other reason—we need your help, the world
needs your help, as Tennyson wrote, “to seek a newer world”. He meant a
better world—more just, more developed, wealthier, more secure and
peaceful, everything good that people want the world to be.
This is an
exceptionally important and difficult time for the United States and for
all the countries represented in your graduating class. We are living in
an age of unparalleled freedom, technological progress and prosperity.
But we also live at a time of unprecedented danger, instability and even
potential cataclysm.
We surely live more
fortunate lives than those of nearly all the generations before us. On
the one hand, the bright side of globalization has given us advantages our
forebears could not have imagined with jet travel narrowing distance and
time, medical advances that allow us to live longer and better, the
information age that has revolutionized the way we live and think, the
spread of democracy on the internet, fiber optics, the spread of capital
to create wealth. These are all good things.
But, the world is
beset by a sea of troubles produced by the dark side of globalization—the
pandemic of 40 million people worldwide living with HIV/AIDs, three
million of whom die annually, including over 500,000 children. Other
destructive, global forces afflict modern life—the power of international
crime and narcotics cartels, global climate change, the spread of
terrorism and the proliferation of biological, chemical and nuclear
technology from the previously secure vaults of nation-states to serve the
irresponsible and evil designs of international terrorist groups. Our
international age has big upsides but also a daunting, forbidding
downside.
The defining feature
of this globalized world is that these transnational threats flow under,
over and right through our national boundaries. No oceans, mountains or
fences are impervious to them. No country, including the United States of
America, can sit back in isolation from them.
This is the great,
global test of our time—how do we cope with this new set of challenges?
The only way I know to spread the bright side of globalization and to
fight the darker side is to join forces on a global basis in concerted
international action. No one country, however powerful, can combat these
incredible problems on its own. We need strong and purposeful global
cooperation to defeat complex, global ills.
This is not a
completely new challenge for the world. The wise people who founded SAIS
also faced a dilemma much like ours nearly sixty years ago in the wake of
the Second World War. They had the foresight and wisdom to create a web
of multilateral institutions that rescued Europe and Asia from the ashes
of war and created the security and prosperity that defined the latter
half of the twentieth century.
Their example can
help us to answer today’s global challenges. We need to rebuild and
re-energize the great multilateral institutions that play such an
important role in organizing the world. And that is beginning to
happen. Since September 11, 2001, for example, the U.S. and the European
Union have combined forces to use our soft power---intelligence sharing,
judicial action, immigration control, economic and diplomatic
pressure---to pursue a war against terrorist cells in our countries. In
London in November, President Bush advocated the importance of “effective
multilateralism” when he called for a new American commitment to rebuild
NATO, and to promote closer ties between the U.S. and EU and to make the
UN itself more effective. In his landmark speech at Whitehall, he said:
“Like eleven Presidents before me, I believe in the international
institutions and alliances that America helped to form and helps to
lead.” He was surely right to set this course for American foreign policy
as was Secretary of State Powell who has highlighted the importance of
partnerships as the keystone of America’s relations with the rest of the
world.
NATO is the best
example of what the President discussed in his speech--an effective
multilateral organization that is vital for both the United States and all
our allies. NATO remains our strongest bridge to Europe and America’s
most important alliance. Left for dead by many of its critics in the
1990s, NATO proved invaluable in stopping the savage wars in Bosnia and
Kosovo and in keeping the peace there to this day. After September 11,
2001, it was abundantly clear to Americans and Europeans alike that we
needed to completely transform NATO’s basic mission as well as its
military capabilities to adjust to the completely new strategic
environment we faced. During the past two years, we’ve changed NATO more
than at any other time in its history. NATO is extending its hand in
partnership well outside of Europe to the arc of countries stretching from
Central and South Asia to the Middle East and North Africa to protect all
of our collective interests. Today NATO is on the ground in Afghanistan
and at sea in the Mediterranean doing just that. Led by Secretary
Rumsfeld, we have completely transformed the military structure and
capabilities of the Alliance for modern missions. NATO and the EU both
added new members this spring, bringing us closer toward constructing the
Europe, whole, free, secure and at peace that has been one of our greatest
strategic aims for half a century. NATO’s new partnerships with Russia
and Ukraine, with the Caucasus and Central Asia, are helping to
consolidate the historic, democratic peace in Europe with those vital
countries.
A few years ago, the
U.S. was accused of neglecting NATO. The irony now is that it is the U.S.
that is advocating the most ambitious roles for NATO in Afghanistan, Iraq
and the Greater Middle East. The U.S. deserves credit for leading the
revival of NATO these last three years.
Still, in the modern
world, multilateral action alone is not always sufficient to resolve tough
problems. In this sense, the United States government and the American
people bear a special responsibility for stability and peace in the
world. At the start of this new century, we Americans find ourselves as
the most powerful country in the world, perhaps the most powerful in
modern history. To channel that power most effectively, we must face the
perennial contradiction that has bedeviled American foreign policy since
the founding of our country more than two hundred years ago. SAIS’
legendary Professor Robert O. Osgood posed this existential question more
than twenty-five years ago--Will America be isolated from the world or
actively engaged in it? The terrible carnage of September 11 surely
convinced most Americans that we have no choice but to be involved in the
world’s affairs and that our historic flirtation with isolationism is an
impossible choice for a country so important to all that happens in the
world. Let us hope that September 11 ended isolationism as a major
force in the U.S. forever because Americans have concluded that we cannot
separate ourselves from a world brought so much closer together by
globalization.
During the last few
years, another ideology has arisen to campaign for a different American
foreign policy in an age of terrorism—the call for America to pursue an
essentially unilateralist course in the world. Some of its proponents,
mainly in think tanks and academia, take an extreme view outside the
mainstream in both political parties. They claim that America’s unique
size, power and mission can be best served by acting outside of what they
see as the constraints of the international community. Some who preach
this gospel say that America’s overwhelming power should lead us to pursue
policies essentially without regard for our alliances, international law
and the multilateral institutions we created decades ago because they
might encumber us, slow us down, restrict our freedom. Some of them
believe NATO’s best days are past or that, with the fall of communism, the
U.S. should no longer accept a multilateral arrangement with NATO in which
we necessarily have to work and compromise with our allies on a daily
basis. For unilateralism’s most extreme proponents, it is not an
exaggeration to say that multilateralism is a symbol of weakness in a
world in which the U.S. must act, they believe, unfettered outside the
boundaries of the international system.
Now, it is certainly
true that the unique nature of America’s role in the world will surely
dictate, as it has in Democratic and Republican administrations alike,
that the U.S. must sometimes act alone, or in small groups to defend the
American people and American interests. But the U.S. can advance those
interests for the long term most effectively through our permanent
alliance in NATO and by nurturing economic cooperation with the EU and by
supporting, as we are, the critical role the United Nations is playing in
forming new governments out of chaos in Afghanistan and Iraq. In fact,
we have had successes in the war against Al Qaida and in stemming
proliferation, precisely because the Bush Administration has worked so
closely with a variety of allies on both fronts, as we are doing in
Afghanistan, North Korea and Libya.
The U.S. can do many
good things in the world on its own. But, we cannot hope to fight
infectious diseases or global environmental challenges or resist AIDs, or
cure river-borne illnesses or certainly stop terrorism all on our own.
The great foreign policy thinker Hans Morgenthau agreed a half a century
ago, “We know that no nation’s power is without limits; and thus we know
that our policies must respect the power and interests of others”.
In short, ladies and
gentlemen, unilateralism is the wrong road at the wrong time to guide
America’s role in the world.
In a complex global
landscape where the pervasive color is often not black and white but gray,
the U.S. cannot rely on the twin illusions of isolationism and
unilateralism to ensure a safe, secure and prosperous future for our
country.
There is a third
way—strong, vital and purposeful American leadership in concert with our
allies and friends around the world in effective multilateralism. This is
surely not an original thought but it is grounded in the experience and
history of America as a global power. In the fourth year of World War
Two, the twelfth year of his presidency and the last year of his life, our
great internationalist President Franklin Roosevelt reminded Americans
what they must always remember about our position in the world: “We have
learned that we cannot live alone at peace. We have learned that our own
well being is dependent on the well being of other nations far away. We
have learned to be citizens of the world, members of the human
community.”
These past few months
have been difficult for the United States, especially in Iraq. The
battles in Falluja and an-Najaf and especially the disgraceful and
appalling prison abuse scandals have tested our strategy, our
self-confidence and our resolve. The fact that we are facing these
challenges openly and with unparalleled transparency is a tribute to our
strong democracy.
It would be a tragic
mistake if Americans concluded from these trials that we would somehow be
better off retreating from the world stage or leaving the hard job of
building peace in inhospitable places like Iraq to others. Such a retreat
would be as equally calamitous as choosing a unilateralist path in the
world. The plain fact is that the world needs American leadership and
engagement as well as America’s vision for the future. While America also
needs NATO, the EU, ASEAN and our many friends around the world to
succeed, it is also true that the world requires America’s military and
economic power, our political energy, our unique blend of optimism and
purpose, to resolve the many problems ahead of us. America must not lose
its confidence and sense of purpose and capacity to do good at a time when
we face dangerous problems. Despite our imperfections, the United States
remains a unique force for good in the world.
If America’s
obligation to the world and to itself is to engage vigorously in the great
multilateral institutions that bind us together, then the rest of the
world has an obligation too. It is to accept that American power,
purpose, energy and optimism are necessary and essential foundations for
world order and progress. And it is to overcome the often gratuitous
anti-Americanism that we see so often in the press and even in public
statements of friendly governments. Anti-Americanism is not worthy of our
alliance of democracies in NATO or in any other part of the world.
Americans understand that our friends are often preoccupied with our role
as a great power in the world. We would ask in return for our friends to
remember that ours is a proud record of support for democracy and freedom
all over the world. You should not wish to see our voice stilled when
there is so much more that we all must do to advance in the world
together.
Ladies and gentlemen
of the graduating class, great and small nations are effective on the
world stage in direct proportion to the talents, wisdom and experience of
their leaders and citizens. This is where you graduates come back in for
the last word. I think you understand how much we need your brainpower
and energy and commitment on all these great issues ahead. Just as
Americans need to realize collectively how important our country is to the
world, you as individuals must believe how vital your individual
contributions can be to our common future. To know and understand history
is to embrace the truth that President Kennedy proclaimed forty years ago;
“One person can make a difference. Every person should try.” I deeply
believe that there is in each of your lives as SAIS graduates and in your
potential, a future Kofi Annan, Paul Nitze, Hamid Karzai, Eleanor
Roosevelt. None of these people accepted as permanent the ills of the
world into which they were born. All of them believed they could make
ours a newer and better world. You can, too.
Ladies and Gentlemen
of the graduating class, like every other generation before you, you are
today called to service. You have role models in this hall today closer
to home who can show you the way forward. Some of your grandparents are
here. They are rightfully called the Greatest Generation because they
overcame the great depression around the world and then triumphed in the
most terrible war of all time. Your parents launched the great crusade to
end racial segregation in America and to give to African-Americans the
rights that should have been theirs since our country’s founding. They
put men and women into space, learned how to transplant hearts and to
condense a library full of books into a single, slender disc in igniting
the information age. They and we are finally granting women equal rights
in the workplace and before the law. In Europe, they survived the
imposition of totalitarianism behind the Iron Curtain and then launched
one of the most important and peaceful revolutions in history by tearing
down the Berlin Wall and restoring democracy to all of Europe. In Asia,
your parents did the impossible-- they created in Japan and South Korea
two of the world’s most powerful nations out of the ashes of war. In
country after country in Asia and the Pacific and in the Americas,
democracy and increasing prosperity took root.
Your grandparents and
parents have spoken the essential human truth that everything is possible
and that your hopes and those of the world for peace can be realized if
you commit yourself to service. As you set out on your paths ahead, we
all hope that you will retain the will to take risks, the strength to be
courageous and the spirit of optimism that has been the foundation for
human progress in all of history.
SAIS has prepared you
well for all the challenges ahead. You will find that the professors who
taught you, the lessons you learned, the friends you made, the alumni
network you will now join will help to sustain you and to keep your course
on the road ahead
So, as you graduate
today, we wish for you the very best—good fortune, success and happiness
in the years to come. And we look forward to following your
accomplishments as you live and write the history of America and of the
world in the century to come.
It is an honor to be
with you on this great day.
Congratulations to
you all!

|